Chihayafuru 10 ~ a woman must always move with grace
December 7, 2011
I truly do love this show. Chihayafuru episode 10 had so many things going on, from the tension around the central love triangle, to personal triumphs and sorrows, all within the larger context of the Tokyo Regional tournament preliminaries. The pacing is excellent. There always seems to be an excellent mixture of pathos and comedy. And to top it all off, the show continues to look great, especially because of Kanade’s condition that everyone must wear hakama in tournaments.
The Tokyo Regional for the national high school championship has begun, and it serves as an excellent vehicle, both for comedy and for drama. Somehow this episode managed to work in interesting mini-stories about four of the five team members, with Nishida mostly playing support. I do think he made one possibly insightful comment, however, that I’ll return to below.
Chihaya is constantly text messaging Arata, even though she gets no response. Taichi believes Arata shares his conviction that, “Chihaya belongs to the both of us”. Oddly this becomes a topic of discussion for various team members over the course of the episode. As I alluded to above, Nishida has a completely different perspective. He thinks she sees Arata as a great Karuta player, and that she wants to play someone strong at the Nationals. Kanade takes the most rabu-rabu interpretation as can be seen in the following screen cap:
When Tsutomu speaks out about Chihaya’s obsession with Arata, he doesn’t add a fresh interpretation, but, by repeating what he heard, he manages to get reactions out of both Chihaya and Taichi. Chihaya’s reaction is somewhat revealing, as she seems to have no idea what Tsutomu is talking about. She is the only character that doesn’t directly offer an interpretation of her relationship with Arata, and the impression we get is that she hasn’t really figured it out herself. Taihi’s reaction to Tsutomu’s outburst was even more revealing:
This was such a great episode that a lot could be said. For example there were several times that Taichi attempted to step in and truly be a leader for his team. To me the most impressive one, however, is the way he defused things just after taking the emotional gut punch we can see in the preceding screen cap. Taichi handles the crisis that Tsutomu created, but he goes on to stop unnecessary criticism of Tsutomu, and to point out a deeper structural flaw in the Karuta club. That he handled the problem so effectively, when the easiest thing would have been to channel the pain he was feeling into rage, shows that Taichi is truly an extraordinary person.
Tsutomu allows his own feelings of frustration and embarrassment to cause even greater difficulties for the whole team. I like the screen cap above. His outburst has put him back where he was before he joined the Karuta club. He sits alone at a desk. In some ways this is his episode. His problem was very believable. It is only reasonable to expect that he would lose repeatedly, and anyone would feel frustrated in such a situation. Of course Tsutomu is hung up on winning more than anyone, as we saw in the episode in which he was introduced (well, anyone outside of Taichi’s mom).
I also REALLY liked the way things were resolved in the end. First Tsutomu comes to a realization that he cares what happens to his new friends. Then Kanade leads him to another realization. The other players at the tournament have calluses on their feet from the many hours they have put in over years kneeling on the tatami mats. This was actually the second great moment in this episode for showing that Kana-chan can be a thoughtful, strong individual. But her words about the effort that everyone had put in, must have made a lot of sense to Tsutomu. In the end he accepts his losses, and is reunited with the club. He also acknowledges Kanade’s win as legitimate, something he had refused to do before.
But the fun doesn’t stop there!
But Mizusawa High (Chihaya’s team) won’t get to face Hokuo for a match unless it wins the semi-final first, and Tsutomu has his breakdown just before the last match of the semi-final. Taichi refuses to let him leave the tournament, but lets him sit out this match. By forfeiting Tsutomu’s hand, Mizusawa High is behind one before the opening poem is even read! To make matters worse, Chihaya’s playing is off.
This one little section was quite interesting. Chihaya is struggling both against the distraction of her emotional anxiety because of the fight the team just had, and also because their opponents are very loud. With her opponents so loud, she has a difficult time putting her hearing ability to good use. But the opposing side also represents the kind of united team that Mizusawa High does not have. As Taichi diagnosed it, they aren’t a team yet, they are playing as individuals. Fortunately Taichi is a good leader, and he manages to get Chihaya to calm down a bit by reminding her to breathe.
This section was put together in such an interesting way. It really held my attention throughout. It had everything you could want in a sports anime, from the pre-game drama that puts them at a disadvantage, to an opposing team that had unwittingly found a way to neutralize the best player, to moments where the team pulled together, and, of course a come from behind victory.